Category Archives: Best of

Our 6 Favorite Ice Cream Pints of All Time – rachael ray every day mag

So many and yet so little time to taste….them all.

Our 6 Favorite Ice Cream Pints of All Time

Looking for your new go-to flavor? Try one of these faves, picked by Rachael Ray Every Day editors. Warning: you might not wanna share.

Ben & Jerry’s Peanut Butter Fudge Core

ben jerrys peanut-butter fudge core

Photo courtesy of Ben & Jerry’s

“It’s pure, unadulterated gluttony, like if a peanut butter cup exploded inside the pint.” —Christina Izzo, features editor 

Buy it on Amazon

Graeter’s Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip

graeters black raspberry chocolate chip

Photo courtesy of Graeter’s

“A signature flavor from this Ohio company that deserves all the hype. Bonus: It’s purple!” —Charles Grayauskie, test kitchen associate

Buy it on Amazon

Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams Brambleberry Crisp

jenis splendid ice creams brambleberry crisp

Photo Courtesy of Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream

“Imagine a blackberry and currant crisp à la mode. Now flip the proportions.” —Geraldine Campbell, executive editor

Buy it at

McConnell’s Eureka Lemon & Marionberries

mcconnells eureka lemon marionberries

Photo Courtesy of McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams

“This pint is so popular, they made a dairy-free version— and it’s also pretty darn delicious.” —Alexa Weibel, senior food editor

Buy it at

Ample Hills Creamery Peppermint Pattie

ample hills creamery peppermint pattie

Photography by Peter Ardito

“Super minty with hunks of candy. This is mint-chip living its best life!” —Nina Elder, executive food editor

Buy it at

Salt & Straw Strawberry Honey Balsamic with Black Pepper

salt straw strawberry honey balsamic black pepper

Ohio’s Homemade Ice Cream

Ohio’s Homemade Ice Cream

Homemade Ice Cream Scoops

This would be about the most perfect way to spend a weekend in Ohio. Road trip.. to any or all of these Ohio’s Homemade Ice Cream shops.  These are just a sampling of what Ohio has to offer!

So you ask…which is the best ice cream? I must be honest with you….I am still searching.  The choices below are some of the best ice creams in Ohio and across the USA.  Enjoy this great article written by Anietra Hamper.

George Dunlap

The Inside Scoop: Ohio’s Homemade Ice Cream

Ohio has deep roots in the dairy industry so it is no surprise that the state produces stellar ice cream. Some of the most famous commercial brands like Graeter’s Ice Cream and Velvet Ice Cream are Ohio-made and each August at the Ohio State Fair some of the best and biggest Vanilla, Strawberry and Chocolate ice cream cones are served up in Dairy Products Building. A number of Ohio-made ice cream establishments are dotted throughout the state. While July 16th marks national ice cream day, a road trip for a superior dip does not require a special occasion.

Young’s Jersey Dairy (Yellow Springs)

After a day of hiking in Yellow Springs, I always stop at Young’s Jersey Dairy for a large scoop of homemade ice cream in a cone. It is the kind of experience that requires catching the first drips quickly due to the size of the scoop. I take advantage of the park-like setting with picnic tables outside to relax and enjoy the moment. Young’s ice cream is made in small batches right on the premises. While Vanilla, Mint Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Peanut Butter are the top selling flavors, the selection changes every month so there is always something new to try.

Tom’s Ice Cream Bowl (Zanesville)

If you ask around for the best homemade ice cream in the state, Tom’s Ice Cream Bowl will come up in conversation. The parlor, that still has many original features is a Zanesville tradition since 1948. There is a reason the word “bowl” is in the name. They serve up overflowing scoops of ice cream that your mother would scold you for dipping at home. The nuts for ice cream are roasted daily and the shop sells old fashioned candy and chocolates. Part of Tom’s appeal is the old-fashioned nostalgia that you feel when you walk through the door. One of the most popular treats is the banana split that is big enough to share.

Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams (Columbus)

I remember years ago going to Columbus’ North Market on Saturday mornings with my mom and walking out with an ice cream treat from the small stall where Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams got its start. Unique flavors like Juniper & Lemon Curd, Genmaicha & Marshmallows or Middle West Whiskey & Pecans promise a flavor combo like you’ve never experienced and that is part of the fun of Jeni’s. Jeni’s has obtained a cult following as much for the unique ice cream flavors as for the way the company sources ingredients like milk from Ohio farms and chocolate and vanilla from small organic farms. Jeni’s has expanded nationwide and there are usually lines out the door for the Ohio homemade ice cream.

Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream  (Youngstown)

When you bite into an ice cream flavor like s’mores you already know the taste to expect, but with Handel’s ice cream you actually get a s’more. Chunks of chocolate and crunchy graham crackers with bites of tiny marshmallows. The flavor is decadent which is why Handel’s has expanded from its Youngstown roots, opening in 1945, to 24 Ohio locations and stores in seven other states. They continue to use old family recipes that originally called for actual ingredients that Mrs. Handel had around the house like fruit from her garden or ingredients in the pantry.

Johnson’s Real Ice Cream (Bexley & Dublin)

The only thing more difficult than selecting a flavor of homemade ice cream at Johnson’s is choosing what to do with it. With a full menu covering a scoop of ice cream in a bowl to spritzers, shakes, floats, and sundaes you need to make several trips just to try some of the unique offerings. I went with the mint chocolate chip shake. It was thick and flavorful. It is no wonder that Johnson’s Real Ice Cream has remained a Central Ohio staple for more than 67 years. The fourth-generation family business that opened its doors in 1950 still makes all of its homemade product in Bexley but distributes its memorable taste to more than 300 restaurants. I am already planning my next visit there this summer.

For more sweet travels, Find It Here at

Sweet Spot, An Ice Cream Binge Across America, by Amy Ettinger

A great read of Amy’s journey tasting and learning about the science and art of Ice Cream.  With over 40 years making, selling, designing ice cream shops, and ice cream recipe consulting I found this book enjoyable and full of good stuff.

Sit back and enjoy Amy Ettinger and her ice cream binge….


5 ice creams to try before summer is over – Chicago Tribune

Food & Dining Food Focus5 ice creams to try before summer is overIce cream tips from the prosDana Cree of The Publican, Leigh Omilinsky of Nico Osteria and Rebecca Zuckerman of Seven Lions Chicago offer tips on serving ice cream at home. (Bill Daley / Chicago Tribune)Bill DaleyChicago Tribune

Vanilla and chocolate are go-to ice cream flavors, but this is the time of year to break the norm and order something new. Why? We’re at peak season for so many fruits — and even vegetables — that go beautifully in ice cream, sorbet or sherbet. Here are some to try before summer runs its course:

Corn and blackberry ice cream at Seven Lions Chicago. Corn! Boy, you can taste it in this Loop restaurant’s sweet-corn and blackberry swirl ice cream. No wonder. Sixteen corn cobs are used to make each batch, says Rebecca Zuckerman, executive pastry chef. $7. 130 S. Michigan Ave., 312-880-0130.

Cassis sorbet at The Publican. Black currants can be so sour they “make your eyes pop out,” says Dana Cree, executive pastry chef for The Publican. But her sorbet, enlivened with verjuice (an extra-tart grape juice), has just the right tang. A scoop comes garnished with a waffle cone wedge. $6. 837 W. Fulton Market, 312-733-9555.

Raspberry sherbet at Monteverde. Chef and co-owner Sarah Grueneberg serves the seasonal sherbet two ways — get it with two blueberry-chocolate cookies ($5) or as part of a more complex dessert created by pastry chef Sara Lamb. For $12, a rich chocolate tart topped with a round of toasted meringue comes with a scoop of the smooth, rose-pink sherbet over a mound of crushed raspberries. 1020 W. Madison St., 312-888-3041.

Blueberry gelato Housemade blueberry jam is mixed into the gelato at Nico Osteria. (Bill Daley / Chicago Tribune)Blueberry-crostata gelato at Nico Osteria. Imagine blueberry cobbler as a gelato, and that’s what you get at this Gold Coast restaurant. Pastry chef Leigh Omilinsky makes a cream-cheese gelato and folds in pecans, bits of pastry crust and housemade blueberry jam. The finished product is more tart than sweet, just the way she wants it. $3 a scoop. 1015 N. Rush St., 312-994-7100.

Corn ice cream at Acadia. The ice cream “truck” dessert on the bar menu at this South Loop restaurant comes with three oval scoops of ice cream (corn, lobster and fennel) and a scoop of lime sorbet. All flavors are almost head-spinningly true to form; for the corn, that means the flavor of biting into an ear of sweet corn teamed with the creamy texture and chilly temperature of ice cream. $10. 1639 S. Wabash Ave., 312-360-9500.

wdaley@chicagotribune.comTwitter @billdaley

Source: 5 ice creams to try before summer is over – Chicago Tribune

BAY AREA LIFE Bay Area LIFE: Mitchell’s Ice Cream is a Bay Area institution

By George Dunlap:  Check out this story of a great C.Nelson friend and customer Mitchell’s in San Fransisco..  I had the privilege to meet with Linda after she purchased her recent C. Nelson ice cream cabinet.  If you are ever in her neighborhood stop and say hello and enjoy some great tasting homemade ice cream.


Foster’s Homemade Ice Cream flavor reviews, photos: Best Ice Cream contest (poll) |

Foster’s Homemade Ice Cream flavor reviews, photos: Best Ice Cream contest (poll)1 / 15

By George Dunlap:  Having had the pleasure to service many of these fine shops in the Cleveland-Akron markets for the past 40 years, i find it very difficult to just pick 1 shop, they are all great tasting ice cream shops.  Enjoy this review of these wonderful Northern Ohio ice cream shops.

Scottwiches are a popular item at Foster’s. Homemade chocolate cookies, made on-site sandwich fresh soft-serve. You can choose between chocolate or vanilla.

Brenda Cain, cleveland.comPrint EmailIda Lieszkovszky, By Ida Lieszkovszky, cleveland.comEmail the authoron August 18, 2016 at 7:31 PM, updated August 18, 2016 at 7:51 PM

WILLOUGHBY HILLS, Ohio — Foster’s Homemade Ice Cream has been operating as an ice cream shop since 1947, and in that time not a whole lot has changed, inside or outside.

That sense of consistency is a big part of Foster’s old-school charm. When owner Jeff Knuth bought the ice cream shop from the previous owner 15 years ago, he bought the recipes for the ice cream along with the building. He even insists on using the same vendors for ingredients that the previous owners did.’s “Best of” team visited Foster’s on Thursday as part of our Best Ice Cream contest. Foster’s is in the running for the best ice cream in the East Region, up against Dairy King in South Euclid and Cibik’s Dairy Island in Chagrin Falls. The winner of this round will advance to the final round of voting, which will determine the winner for the overall Best Ice Cream in Greater Cleveland for 2016.

Source: Foster’s Homemade Ice Cream flavor reviews, photos: Best Ice Cream contest (poll) |

5 Awesome Philly-Area Ice Cream Shops | Foobooz

5 Ice Cream Shops That are Worth the Drive From retro soda shops to on-the-farm dairies, these are sweet spots are destinations unto themselves.By Philly Mag Staff | July 30, 2016 at 9:00 pm

The counter at West Chester Coffee & Ice Cream Bar | Photograph by Jauhien SasnouThe counter at West Chester Coffee & Ice Cream Bar. | Photograph by Jauhien SasnouFranklin Fountain, Old City’s destination ice cream shop, might get all the buzz, but these retro soda shops and on-the-farm dairies are equally sweet spots to get your brain freeze on. We promise:

These ice cream shops are all more than worth the trip.For a country treat: Chester Springs Creamery at Milky Way Farm The coolest thing about this working Chester Springs farm and dairy is that every single cow has a name, and every single ice cream in the creamery is attributed to one of them. So when you pop into the big, bright ice-cream shop on the top of the hill, you’ll be scoring a cone of Melody’s mocha chip or Bessie’s black raspberry. Don’t limit your visits to summer: Come fall, you can score Abby’s apple cinnamon ice cream.521 East Uwchlan Avenue, Chester Springs.

For small-town charm: The Wayne Coffee & Ice Cream Bar You’d think a subterranean ice-cream shop would feel gloomy. But this spot nestled in the basement of the Suburban Building is cheery, airy, and just retro enough, with Hamilton Beach milkshake machines and expanses of shiny white marble. Head here or to its newer sister shop, West Chester Coffee & Ice Cream Bar, for goods from local and small-batch vendors: ice cream from Philly’s Little Baby’s, Chester Springs’s Scooped and Ohio cult-favorite Graeter’s, plus daily-baked doughnuts and fresh coffee.134 North Wayne Avenue, Wayne, and 6 East Gay Street, West Chester.

For waffles with your ice cream: Nina’s Waffles This four-year-old ice cream shop nestled on a quiet corner at the top of a steep hill in New Hope is cozy and quaint, with iron chairs, wooden tables and authentic roots. (Owner Louis Zanias is from Belgium, so the waffles are the real deal.) But don’t mistake it for a tiny operation: This is one of a quartet of locations (the latest opened in Princeton in April; the New Hope flagship at 31 West Mechanic Street is still our favorite), plus a trio of food trucks. But what they serve up would be just as good if it came from a rickety stand on some Brussels side street: a scoop of homemade salted caramel ice cream atop a fresh-from-the-iron Liège waffle.Multiple locations.

Sponsored ContentSuggested: Best of Philly Soirée Preview: Stella Artois  Airstream For a (literal) taste of history:

Bassetts Ice Cream This is the destination for ice-cream devotees looking to snag a scoop from the oldest parlor in America. (Bassetts was founded in 1861 and settled here in Reading Terminal Market in 1892.) Original marble countertops now share space with modern additions like digital HD menu boards, and the stand is always clogged with crowds, but it’s still worth a trip — yes, even for the most jaded, tourist-hating Philadelphian.12th and Arch Streets

Source: 5 Awesome Philly-Area Ice Cream Shops | Foobooz

The 11 best artisanal ice cream flavors in Chicago right now –

Chicago right now11 best artisanal ice cream flavors in Chicago right now11 best artisanal ice cream flavors in Chicago right now (Lenny Gilmore / RedEye)Morgan OlsenMorgan OlsenContact ReporterI scream, you scream, we all scream for something that will cool us off on an insufferably hot summer day. And while the freezer aisle has plenty of classics to choose from (hello, Choco Taco, old friend), we’re thinking bigger. It’s time to upgrade your ice cream game and check out some of Chicago’s tastiest artisanal scoops.

We sampled offerings from across the city and picked the best chef-crafted pints you can pick up at a restaurant or retailer near you. From a light, bright grapefruit-prosecco sorbet to a sinfully decadent chocolate-marshmallow treat, there’s something for every ice cream connoisseur.

1. Dulce cayenne ($10 per pint or three for $25) from Siena Tavern51 W. Kinzie St. 312-595-1322Decadent dulce de leche-infused ice cream is generously studded with caramelized nibs and sprinkled with a hint of ground cayenne pepper. In other words, you won’t want to share.

2. Caramelized banana chocolate chip ($5.50 per half-pint or $2.95 per quarter-pint) from Americano 22112211 W. North Ave. 773-360-8757This frozen delight captures the essence of fresh-baked chocolate chip banana bread perfectly. Just like Mom made it. Pro tip: Grab a few TCHO chocolate chip cookies ($1.75 each) while you’re there and make your own ice cream sandwiches at home.

3. Cherry cobbler gelato ($9 per pint) from Nico OsteriaFind it at Publican Quality Meats, 825 W. Fulton Market 312-445-8977Say hello to summer in a pint. Cream cheese-vanilla gelato is pumped full of tart cherry jam and crumbly cobbler pieces.

4. Chicago coffee ($8.50 per pint) from Ruth & Phils Gourmet Ice Cream 636 W. Chicago Ave. 872-802-4868Beans from local favorite Dark Matter Coffee are ground, steeped overnight in cream and sugar and then jammed into this intense java-flavored concoction. Because eating your coffee is way more fun than drinking it.

5. Lemon olive oil ($10 per pint or three for $25) from Siena Tavern 51 W. Kinzie St. 312-595-1322Bits of bright lemon zest, swirls of creamy olive oil and a hint of sea salt mingle in perfect harmony, creating a scoop that could cool you down on the hottest summer day.

6. Pineapple basil sorbet ($8.75-$10.75) from Black Dog Gelato 859 N. Damen Ave. 773-235-3116 Basil is boss in this soft, pineapple-perfumed treat that’s both refreshing and insanely addictive. You don’t need a bowl or a cone—you’ll want to eat this one straight from the pint.

7. Spumoni ($5.99 per pint) from Homer’s Find it at Olivia’s Market, 2014 W. Wabansia Ave. 773-227-4220We cheated with this suburban staple, but with retailers in the city, there’s no drive required to get your hands on this three-in-one dessert with cherry, pistachio and chocolate ice creams layered in one perfect pint.

8. Pistachio ($10 per pint) from Bar Siena 832 W. Randolph St. 312-492-7775Huge chunks of pistachio swim in a pristine pool of nutty goodness. Pick up a pint at the West Loop restaurant or hit Bombo Bar, their grab-and-go dessert window, where you’ll inevitably be tempted to get your scoop served between two cookies ($6) if you can’t commit to a pint.

9. Strawberry shortcake ($10 per pint) from David Burke’s Primehouse 616 N. Rush St. 312-660-6000The seasonal pop-up ice cream shop is back in full effect, and this week’s flavor (available Friday from 4-6 p.m.) remixes a classic summer dessert. Perfectly pink strawberry ice cream is served with shortcake pieces, lemon gelee and strawberry sauce as optional toppings.

10. Grapefruit prosecco sorbet ($5.50 per half-pint or $2.95 per quarter-pint) from Americano 22112211 W. North Ave. 773-360-8757You know that feeling you get when you walk into an air-conditioned place on a 100-degree day? This guilt-free sorbet is a lot like that. An explosion of citrus meets you up front and fades into a delicate, summery taste that lingers long after you scrape the bottom of the container.

11. Raspberry peach ($10 per pint) from Bar Siena 832 W. Randolph St. 312-492-7775Just like your favorite summer pie served a la mode, this ice cream is loaded with hunks of juicy raspberries and tart peaches. Pick up a pint at the West Loop restaurant or hit BomboBar, their grab-and-go dessert window.| @morgancolsen

Source: The 11 best artisanal ice cream flavors in Chicago right now –